A vice president of sales resigned on a Thursday and started at a direct competitor the following Monday. He took a customer list of 1,140 accounts with him on a personal drive.
Results
A ledger of representative matters, with the forum and the outcome for each.
Twelve representative matters, including two we lost
Client names are withheld. Forums and outcomes are not. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
Employment disputes
6 of 388 matters
File no.MatterForumOutcomeYear
H-0612
Defense of a 340-employee wage class action against a regional freight company
Superior Court, Suffolk County
Class certification denied; settled at 6% of the damages claimed
2025
H-0598
Enforcement of a non-compete against a departing sales vice president of a medical device maker
U.S. District Court, District of Massachusetts
Preliminary injunction granted nine days after engagement
2025
H-0544
Retaliation claim brought by a former chief financial officer against a biotech employer
Jury trial, Middlesex County
Defense verdict after a six-day trial
2024
H-0531
Age discrimination claim by a regional director against a hospital system
Jury trial, Suffolk County
Verdict for the plaintiff of $310,000, reduced by a third on appeal
2024
H-0507
Independent investigation of a harassment complaint against a founder and chief executive
Special committee of the board
Report delivered in 19 days; findings adopted in full
2023
H-0466
Defense of a software executive sued on a two-year non-compete
Business Litigation Session, Boston
Injunction denied; covenant held unenforceable
2022
Commercial disputes
6 of 252 matters
File no.MatterForumOutcomeYear
H-0571
Earn-out claim for the three sellers of a payroll software company
Commercial arbitration, Boston
Award of $4.2 million plus legal fees
2024
H-0553
Wrongful termination of a supply contract, brought against a contract manufacturer
U.S. District Court, District of Massachusetts
Summary judgment for our client on all counts
2024
H-0519
Deadlock between the two equal owners of a nine-location restaurant group
Business Litigation Session, Boston
Court-ordered buy-out at our client's valuation
2023
H-0498
Freeze-out claim by a minority shareholder in a family distribution business
Mediation, Essex County
Shares bought at 2.1 times the opening offer
2023
H-0472
Breach of a software licensing agreement by a former reseller
Commercial arbitration, New York
Claim dismissed; our client paid $180,000 in costs
2022
H-0451
Indemnity claim after the sale of a clinical staffing company
Commercial arbitration, Boston
$1.9 million recovered on a $2.4 million claim
2021
Decided or resolved for our client Decided against our client
One matter in detail: nine days to an injunction
File H-0598, described with the client's permission and without its name.
- 9 daysfrom first call to injunction
- 2lawyers on the matter
- $86,400total fees, within budget
Julia Raines and Dana Whitfield had a forensic image of his laptop by Saturday. They filed for a preliminary injunction on day four and argued it in federal court on day nine.
The court barred him from 212 named accounts for twelve months. The case settled six weeks later, with the list returned and our client's fees paid by the other side.
Three clients on how it went, including one who lost
Published with permission. Job titles are as they were when each matter closed.
Their investigation report was the first one our board read to the last page. It said what happened, in order, and what we should do on Monday.
We lost at trial. Harbor had put the odds in writing a year earlier, and they were right about the trial and right about the appeal.
Two owners, one company and no way out. Renata got us a buy-out without a single restaurant closing for a single night.